|
PART
III The Reviews
(From
THE BIG DEAL ABOUT POCKET OPTICS,
March, 2002, BirdWatcher's Digest)
by
Diane and Michael Porter
|
|
These are
some of the pocket binoculars our judges found noteworthy. Click
on any of the binocular images below for a bigger version of
the picture.
Bausch
& Lomb
Custom Compact 7x26
Reverse Porro Prism
This compact
binocular is bright and clear and focuses to 8 feet. It weighs
only 13 ounces and has generous eye relief (16mm) for eyeglass
wearers. You sense the good engineering the moment you pick
it up and smoothly turn the focus wheel (prominent and easy
to access even with gloves on). The body is all black. The upper
surface has an easily gripped texture. The Custom Compact will
undoubtedly continue as a perennial favorite of birders.
Bausch
& Lomb
Legacy 10x24
Reverse Porro Prism
For an
inexpensive binocular, this compact model with fully multicoated
lenses turned in a respectable performance on our optical tests.
Its ergonomics impressed us, with all the moving parts offering
just the right amount of resistance. The surface is nonslip
black, and the inch-long focus knob has a textured rubber surface,
for a sure grip even with a heavily gloved finger. If you like
understated embellishments, you'll appreciate the thin gold
band around the base of each eyepiece.
The Legacy
has a decent close focus of 10 feet and generous eye relief
(16mm). The eyecups extend by twisting out. Surprisingly for
binoculars in this price range, the Legacy is waterproof. The
only complaint anyone put forward was that it hangs almost horizontally,
and if the wearer walks fast or jogs, it tends to flop around
with each step.
|
INDIVIDUAL REVIEWS
|
B&L
Custom Compact
B&L Legacy
Brunton Eterna
Deutsche Optik
Eagle
Leica
Meade
Minox
Nikon Travelite
Olympus
Opticron
Pentax Roofs
Pentax Porros
Swarovski
Swift
Weaver
Zeiss
New
Zeiss
|
THE
BIG DEAL ABOUT POCKET OPTICS
|
PART
I
Why
Get Pocket Binoculars?
Part
II
Features
to Look For in Pocket Binoculars
Part
1V
Chart of Pocket Binoculars
|
MORE
ON BIRDING OPTICS
|
|
Deutsche
Optik
B/Ga Compact 8x22
Roof Prism
This is
a nice-looking roof prism binocular with the surest-grip rubberized
surface of any pocket binoculars in our survey. The gray and
black body looks stylish. The focus wheel sits at the end of
the bridge, like the pocket Swarovskis, allowing the ring or
little finger to do the focusing and leaving the other fingers
free to stabilize the binocular. It compared well to other 8x
binoculars on the optical resolution tests. With an eye relief
of 14mm, it allowed some but not all of our judges to see the
entire field of view while wearing glasses. Although the B/Ga
Compact is not waterproof, it is water resistant. Just don't
drop it in the stream. It also comes in 10x25.
Eagle
Optics
Triumph 8x25 and 10x25
Reverse Porro Prism
The Eagle
Optics Triumph is an excellent choice for a first binocular. It has decent optics, and it won't break the bank. If you get serious about birding, or if you get richer, you can move up to a high-end binocular without regret. This one can become your loaner, so that you can take a friend birding with you and let them in on the fun.
Leica
Trinovid BCA 8x20 and 10x25
Roof Prism
If small
and good are what you're looking for, consider the 8x20 Leica
Trinovid. Folding to 1-1/2 inches thick, this binocular would
actually fit in a shirt pocket. The Trinovid ties with the Swarovski
8x20 as the most pocketable binoculars we tested. With the usual
excellent, bright Leica optics, it ties with Swarovski and Zeiss
for widest field of view in the smallest package (8x roof prisms).
All external lenses have Leica's HDC High Durability Coating,
which gives extra protection against scratches.
Ergonomics?
It's easy to hold. The focus knob falls naturally between the
thumb and index finger of either hand. It provides good eye
relief (14mm) and pop-up eyecups. It hangs at an ideal angle
for lying flat against the chest. The diopter adjustment is
at the far end of the right eyepiece, out of the way and safe
from being moved accidentally.
The slightly
longer 10x25 model focuses down to 16.4 feet (as opposed to
9.8 for the 8x). Both of these pocket Leicas are water resistant
but not waterproof or submersible.
|
|
Meade
Travel View 8x25
Reverse Porro Prism
These were
the least expensive binoculars in our survey. Nevertheless,
their optical resolution score equaled that of a number of more
expensive 8x brands. The field of view at 1,000 yards is a generous
426 feet, which is good for viewing sports events. However,
the eye relief of 12mm is insufficient for many people who wear
glasses.
Minox
BD 8x24 and 10x25
Roof Prism
Eyeglass
wearers will appreciate the 17mm of eye relief, which allows
virtually everyone to enjoy the full field of view through the
10x25 binocular. The 8x24 version is even better, at 18mm. Nicely
engineered eyecups twist up and snap into position. Both models
focus closer than 10 feet. The 10x25 won an excellent score
for optical resolution. With a nonslip surface, these are attractive
binoculars, attractively priced.
|
|
Nikon
Travelite V 8x25
Reverse Porro Prism
The Nikon
Travelite, long a favorite of birders, once again proves its
appeal. It's bright and crisp. It focuses reasonably close,
at 9.8 feet, and has decent eye relief of 14mm. It's also comfortable
in the hand and has a pleasant nonslip surface. The focus knob,
with a ribbed, nonslip surface, turns smoothly and is big enough
to find easily, even when wearing gloves. At 9 ounces, it's
one of the lighter pocket Porros. It comes also in 10x25.
Olympus
PC 1 8x25
Reverse Porro Prism
This is
an amazing little Porro, well made, bright, and sharp. It did
as well as or better than the most expensive binoculars in our
optical resolution tests. It offers a close focus of 8.2 feet.
At 16.5mm, the eye relief is one of the best, for those who
wear glasses as well as those who do not.
The inch-long
focus knob is rubberized and textured for an easy grip even
to gloved fingers. It hangs well, tending to clasp the wearer's
chest rather than bouncing around with each step. It's silver
and gray, the gray part of which is a nonslip surface. It also
comes in 10x25.
Opticron
Taiga 8x25
Reverse Porro Prism
This is
a remarkable little binocular for less than $100. It focuses
down to 8.2 feet. The eye relief of 18mm is about as good as
it gets. The ribbed, rubberized focus knob turns smoothly and
is big enough to find even with gloves on. The lens caps twist
up, allowing for easy sharing between a person who wears glasses
and one who does not.
Opticron
Aspheric LE 8x25
Roof Prism
This inexpensive
roof prism model ought to get a prize for having the longest
eye relief (22mm) of anything in our survey. Furthermore, its
close focus of 6.6 feet was among the best of the lot. It's
black with a slender silver band around the base of each eyepiece.
The focus
knob is a thin cylinder that barely clears the top of the binoculars.
It turns a bit stiffly and might be a little hard to get a grip
on with a gloved finger. The eyecups are our favorite design,
twist-ups, but they seem rather loose and sometimes twist back
down when you want them up.
|
|
New
Pentax Pocket Binoculars
This update was added in January, 2003
Pentax
DCF MP
Roof Prism
8x28 and 10x28
These
are a bit larger (15.5 oz.) than the other pocket binoculars
in this review, but we're adding them here because they are
still quite compact. This is an outstanding, waterproof
compact binocular.
It has
20mm of eye relief, making it one of the few high-quality pocket
binoculars useful to glasses wearers. We appreciate the build
quality, the excellent optics, and the careful attention to
design.
Twist-out
eyecups are great for dialing justthe amount of eye relief you
need for your particular glasses (or lack thereof). Close focus
is 9 feet.
*********************************************
The original
review from the 2000 BirdWatcher's Digest article, below, was
for the Pentax DCF MC. Pentax has discontinued that model
and replaced it with the DCF MP, described above.
DCF MC 10x25 DISCONTINUED BY PENTAX
Roof Prism
Among
10x binoculars of any size, it's hard to find ones that let
an eyeglass-wearer see the whole picture. This pocket Pentax
does. Furthermore, it focuses at 6.6 feet, closer than any other
10x binoculars we tested.
Slim
and lightweight, it is sturdy and well engineered, with twist-up
eyecups and a diopter adjustment with just the right degree
of resistance. The two barrels are black, with a subtle pattern
in the nonslip covering, contrasting with the stainless steel
bridge. It also comes in an 8x22 model, which focuses to a respectable
9.8 feet.
Pentax
UCF X 8x25
Reverse Porro Prism
The UCF
X is one of the largest of the pocket binoculars we reviewed,
but at 11 ounces it's still a light load to carry. It focuses
startlingly close, at 6.2 feet. It's smooth focusing, bright,
and easy to handle, and has a smooth, responsive focus knob.
On some
binoculars, the slightest bump undoes the diopter adjustment.
Others are hard to move. The Pentax UCF X locks the adjustment
with a button that must be pushed before the diopter adjustment
will move. Another nice touch is the way the strap snaps securely
and instantly into place. The eyepieces pop up, and there is
a halfway position, for a user with a prominent brow or close-fitting
glasses.
Pentax
UCF WR 8x24
Reverse Porro Prism
This is
another fairly large model that slides into our "pocket"
category by weighing in just under 13 ounces. It shares some
features of the UCF X: locking diopter adjustment, snap-in straps,
and pop-up eyepieces. In addition it is waterproof and nitrogen
filled.
Swarovski
8x20and 10x25
Roof Prism
We've learned
to expect outstanding binoculars from Swarovski, and they did
not disappoint us. The trim, elegant 8x20 (shown at right) ties
with the Leica for most pocketable binoculars, and it ties with
Leica and Zeiss for the best field of view among the 8x roofs.
The eyecups
twist up, allowing you to dial the amount of eye relief you
need for glasses. The focus knob is at the far end of the bridge,
where it can be turned by the ring or little finger, leaving
the other fingers free to stabilize the binoculars. This is
an unusual arrangement but one that some birders swear by after
they try it. These Swarovskis are waterproof, fogproof, and
submersible.
|
|
Swift
Trekker ZWCF (A) 8x26
Reverse Porro Prism
The Trekker
has a pleasant non-slip surface and feels good in the hand.
It was in the top group of 8x binoculars for optical resolution.
The eye relief (14mm) is sufficient for most users to see the
whole picture even while wearing glasses. However, the focus
knob is stiff, and the rubber eyecups are a bit hard to fold
down.
Swift
Micron CF (A) 8x25 and 10x22
Reverse Porro Prism
The gray
and black 10x22, shown at right, weighing in at 5.25 ounces,
was the lightest weight model we looked at. It focuses no closer
than 22 feet. It is waterproof.
The black
8x25 weighs 11 ounces. It will let you look at butterflies only
8 feet away, but it's not waterproof.
Both models
have an eye relief of 8mm, making them suitable only for people
who do not wear glasses.
|
|
Weaver
Compact 8x24 and 10x28
Roof Prism
These moderately
priced pocket roofs proved themselves to be right up there with
the best pocket binoculars in optical resolution. They have
a pleasant nonslip black surface, a neat, slim appearance, and
they're waterproof.
The 8x24
costs half as much as the other waterproof 8x binoculars with
equally high resolution scores. Some of our judges wished they
would focus closer than 17 feet and had longer than 10mm eye
relief. But if close focus is not a primary concern, a birder
who does not wear glasses may find a great bargain in these
binoculars.
Zeiss
ClassiC 8x20 and 10x25
Roof Prism
These miniature
Zeiss ClassiCs are among the tiniest of the pocket binoculars.
The 10x25 shares with the Leica 10x25 the title for the greatest
power of resolution of all the binoculars we tested. They have
good eye relief (14mm), and they hang perfectly vertical. They
use Zeiss's "T multilayer anti-reflective coatings."
The knurled
focus knob rides on one hinge, and the diopter adjustment is
the smooth knob on the other hinge. The binoculars are "double
jointed"you can fold the hinges either way, so you
can turn them upside down and use the index finger of your preferred
hand for focusing. And they're waterproof.
*************************************************
New
Zeiss Pocket Binoculars!
This update is being added in January, 2003
Wow!
We love the new Zeiss
Victory pocket binoculars. In fact, we liked them so
much we're going to have to buy a pair for ourselves. The 8x20
is so compact and light weight (just 8 ounces) you don't even
remember you're carrying it -- until you see a bird and remember
the purpose of your life. This tiny binocular focuses as close
as 10 feet.
The
10x25
is a little longer in the barrel, but at 8.6 ounces still remarkably
un-heavy and compact. At a close focus of 18 feet, it's not
quite so good on this score as the 8x20. But both have a lovely,
non-slip rubberized surface that feels nice to the hand. All
black. Their appearance says "craftsmanship."
Both models
are incredibly sharp, and waterproof! The design is asymmetrical.
The hinge is left of center. That lets you fold the left barrel
tightly against the right barrel.
In
the photos, the eyecups are pulled out, for people who don't
wear glasses. Push the eyecups in to accommodate people who
do wear glasses.
Diane says:
I love these binoculars! Absolutely love them.
PART
I Why
Get Pocket Optics?
PART
II Features to look for
in pocket binoculars
PART
IV Chart of Pocket Optics
to see which binoculars include the features you care about
most.
|
|
Home FAQ Tips
Stories Videos
Software Optics
Bookstore Orders
|