Top
Birding Scopes
Personally Reviewed
by Michael
and Diane Porter
 Michael
and Diane Porter and a team of Iowa birders tested the top birding scopes
for Bird Watcher's Digest (July, 2000). Here are their findings.
How
we tested the scopes
How
we scored the scopes optically
Reviews of individual scopes
How we tested
the birding scopes
Because
zooms tend to be popular with birder, we tested scopes with zoom eyepieces
installed whenever possible. For the smaller scopes, we tested at 20x
and 40x, and the large scopes at 20x, 40x, and 60x. If only a fixed eyepiece
was available, the scores of those tests include an "F" in the chart.
Note: these results
show the combined optical quality of both the scope and the zoom eyepiece.
Fixed eyepieces undoubtedly would have produced different results. Also,
we tested only one sample of each scope, and it might have been atypical.
How we scored
the birding scopes
We tested all the scopes at the same distance and under similar lighting
conditions. The resolution test chart we used had progressively smaller
groups of lines. To the smallest group we were able to resolve, we assigned
a score of 20; the next larger group 19, then 18, etc. The difference
in resolution between two consecutive scores was small but perceptible.
Much of the time
birders use scopes at 20x, and you'll notice that at 20x most of the test
scores don't vary a great deal. We were impressed at the high quality
of the scopes we tested. In choosing the right scope for you, the ergonomic
qualities, such as size, weight, and focusing method, might outweigh a
small difference in optical quality.
REVIEWS
of individual scopes
Bausch
& Lomb
Brandon (Vernon)
Bushnell Spacemaster
Deutsche Optik Optolyth
Eagle Optics Raven
Fujinon
Kowa
Leica
Nikon
Pentax
Questar
Swarovski
Swift
Tele Vue Ranger
Zeiss (new review,
added Jan. 2003)
The
Scopes at a Glance - A Chart
Here we tabulate the essential specs on all the scopes we tested and their
closely-related models.
Home FAQ Tips
Stories Videos
Software Optics
Bookstore Orders
|